It's strange how things in your career come together over time. Way back in 2008 I was attending TechEd in Orlando, Florida (as documented here
). We had a booth the first week to lauch our Sonar product (which eventually became part of SharePoint Diagnostic Manager
) and I was lurking about the Office kiosks the second week answering SharePoint development questions when I got roped into something called Speaker Idol. It was a fun little competition in which speakers are given five minutes to do a presentation to a panel of judges and a small audience. The winner of each heat went on to the finals with the prize being a speaking slot at the next TechEd. By pure luck I managed to win the competition and along the way met some really great people - the irrepressible Rachel Appel
, the eloquent Alan Stevens
, and the brilliant Amanda Leigh
, to name just a few. But perhaps the best connections to come out of that event were with Richard Campbell and Carl Franklin
, a dynamic duo who have brought us such great technical community resources as .NET Rocks
, RunAs Radio
, and The Tablet Show
, not to mention speaking, producing, traveling cross-country on insane road trips and, oh yeah, making some killer music
Richard and I have gotten together a few times over the years, both virtually and in person, to chat about various techincal topics - usually SharePoint - and I'm always amazed how much he knows about the technology industry in general and especially about our little corner of it. You would think his mind is already overflowing with general tech-related buzz but somehow he keeps his finger on the pulse of the SharePoint world as well. I really don't think he sleeps. Like, ever. I had another opportunity to chat with Richard recently on the topic of SharePoint search (and SharePoint/Office365/Azure/Cloud stuff in general) for RunAs Radio. I always enjoy our conversations and we never seem to have enough time to talk about everything on our minds. In any event, have a listen if you are so inclined and be sure to check out all the other things Richard is involved in. It's quality stuff!
Take the trouble out of troubleshooting.
One of the most common requirements in any SharePoint environment is the aggregation and summarization of content across lists, libraries, sites and site collections. Administrators could not easily achieve these requirements without custom code until the introduction of the Content Query Web Part (CQWP) in SharePoint 2007/2010. The CQWP gave administrators a useful out-of-the-box method for collecting data from various lists into a consolidated view. Even better, it could aggregate data from different sites – something the built-in List View Web Parts could never do. But, the CQWP certainly has its limitations – the number of sites it can query is limited, modifying the display requires expert XSL transformation skills, and the behind-the-scenes heavy lifting required to execute its queries can place a significant load on the infrastructure, especially when used on heavily trafficked pages...
Take the trouble out of troubleshooting.
If you have managed to successfully configure User Profile Synchronization in your 2013 environment (which is a daunting task in and of itself) then at some point you are going to have to deal with the personal sites of users who have been disabled or removed from Active Directory. SharePoint tries to be helpful in this regard by identifying account status changes during the synchronization process, deleting user profiles from the database, and notifying the user's manager (if there is one) of the fact that the associated My Site will be deleted in a couple of weeks. Unfortunately, this notification leads to a bit of confusion as the manager can't actually browse to the user's My Site from the provided link. Here's a sample of the system-generated email notification:
The My Site of [USERNAME] is scheduled for deletion in 14 days. As their manager you are now the temporary owner of their site. This temporary ownership gives you access to the site to copy any business-related information you might need. To access the site use this URL: https://[MY SITEHOST]/personal/[USERID]
The above email is generated when the My Site Cleanup Job timer job runs, at which time the user's manager is also added to the Site Collection Administrators group of the target My Site. Trouble is, the link itself doesn't work – browsing to it invokes the PersonalSpaceRedirect control on the default.aspx page for the SPSPERS site template, which checks to see if the current user is the site owner; if not, it redirects to the "person.aspx" page on the My Site host. Note that it specifically checks the site owner and secondary contact properties – it does not check to see what groups the user is a member of. So even though the manager has been given full control of the site collection they still get redirected to person.aspx whenever they try to browse to the My Site default home page.
This would be fine, as the standard links on the redirection page allow for navigation to the deleted user's OneDrive folder and from there to Site Settings and Site Contents, except for one major problem – as soon as person.aspx loads it errors out and the manager gets the ever-so-friendly "An error has occurred" page. For once, the error actually says what the problem is: "User not found". Why? Because the user's profile has already been removed from the profile database during the synchronization process. The page is dynamic, attempting to load the user information from the account name passed in the query string argument, but since there is no such user to be found anymore it throws an error.
The good news is that the original user's My Site is actually still there (well, it's there for 14 days, anyway – after that it's gone). If you know the SharePoint URL structure you can still browse to various system pages like "/_layouts/settings.aspx" and "/_layouts/viewlsts.aspx", as well as certain lists, including "/documents" (the user's OneDrive folder). This is fortunate, as user's don't have the ability to delete the core Documents folder, so if the manager knows the ropes they can just append "/documents" to the end of the link in the email and they're good to go. But not everyone knows this so it would be helpful if the link could be changed to point to the Documents folder instead of the home page but it cannot – there's no supported way (that I've been able to find) to modify the notification email. And this functionality remains broken even after SP1 and the June 2014 CU for SharePoint 2013 (seriously, who tests this stuff – anyone at all?).
So what can we do? Well, if you're up for it, you can write your own My Site cleanup timer job as Kirk Evans describes in this blog post (which is also good reading for background on the entire synchronization and cleanup process). If you want to modify the length of time before a deleted user's My Site is removed, change the email text, or otherwise make changes to the overall process then this is your only option. But what if you just want to address the broken person.aspx redirect problem? Unfortunately, you still need some custom code, but there is a way to do it that's not quite as painful as writing a custom timer job. I'll walk you through a quick solution that I came up with – there are probably a dozen other ways to do this but it solves the problem in a supported way with minimal code to maintain.
At the root of the problem is the PersonalSpaceRedirect control. You can find the control reference by opening the C:\Program Files\Common Files\microsoft shared\Web Server Extensions\15\TEMPLATE\SiteTemplates\SPSPERS\default.aspx file on any SharePoint web server (NOTE: Please don't modify this file directly – that's unsupported and a bad practice in general). Below all the control registrations and page directives you'll find this bit of markup:
<asp:Content contentplaceholderid="PlaceHolderPageTitleInTitleArea" runat="server">
<SPSWC:PersonalSpaceRedirect runat="server" />
<SPSWC:LabelLoc TextLocId="My SiteContentText" runat="server" />
As mentioned above, this control handles redirection for users who aren't the site owner of a given My Site by checking the site owner and secondary contact properties, and if the user is neither of those then it sends them to the person.aspx page instead (if you'd like to investigate it yourself you can find it in the Microsoft.SharePoint.Portal.WebControls assembly using ILSpy or Reflector). Naturally, the My Site Cleanup Job doesn't make the manager a site owner or secondary contact, it simply adds them to the Site Collection Administrators group. Although the control itself is public several of the dependent methods are not so extending the control with a custom implementation that works properly isn't feasible and completely replacing it with a custom Site Definition is a lot more trouble than it's worth. Instead, we can preempt the behavior of this control by adding a custom redirection control of our own to the page using the delegate control mechanism of SharePoint.
If you've never worked with delegate controls before the underlying principle is simple: they are server controls which get "stapled" to a parent control to provide a method for injecting code into each page in a site, site collection, web application or farm (depending upon how they are scoped). By selecting one of the out of the box controls in the default master pages (or a customized master page with similar markup) that accepts multiple child controls we can add our own logic to the page at runtime. Using this method we can write our own redirection control which checks the group membership of the current user and, if they are a site collection administrator but not a site owner or secondary contact, redirect them to a page which doesn't have the PersonalSpaceRedirect control – like the default OneDrive "Documents" library.
[NOTE: Delegate controls are full-trust code and therefore not compatible with the SharePoint 2013 App Model or Office 365]
Creating a delegate control is pretty simple (refer to this link for a step-by-step walkthrough). Create a new empty SharePoint project in Visual Studio 2013 using the "Full Trust" option and add a new class. Then override the OnInit event with the code you want to run or a method reference (I prefer using method references whenever possible for testability purposes):
namespace BinaryWave.SP.My Site
public class PageRedirector : WebControl
protected override void OnInit(EventArgs e)
Next, add a new method with logic to check the user's group membership and redirect them to the "Documents" library.
protected void RedirectUser()
SPWeb web = SPContext.Current.Web;
if (web.WebTemplate == "SPSPERS")
SPSite site = web.Site;
SPUser user = web.CurrentUser;
string targetUrl = web.Url + "/Documents";
string welcomeUrl = web.RootFolder.WelcomePage;
if (web.UserIsSiteAdmin || site.UserIsSiteAdminInSystem)
if (site.Owner.LoginName.ToLower() != user.LoginName.ToLower())
catch (System.Exception ex)
You can then add an empty SharePoint element to the project and edit the Elements.xml file to specify which control on the page your new delegate control will be stapled to. I chose "AdditionalPageHead" as it normally can be found at the top of a default master page (if you are using a custom master page you may need to alter the control reference). Note that you will need the full assembly name and public key token values for your project – you can get these by compiling the project and using the Strong Name Tool in Visual Studio.
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<Control Id="AdditionalPageHead" ControlAssembly="BinaryWave.SP.My Site, Version=220.127.116.11, Culture=neutral, PublicKeyToken=3a29866fd9ac8366" ControlClass="BinaryWave.SP.My Site.PageRedirector" />
A Feature will have already been created in the project once the empty element was added –edit this Feature to change the name, description, etc. If you have chosen to configure your My Site Host as a separate web application then the Feature should be scoped to "Web Application" and deployed to that specific web application. If your My Site host is in the same web application as your primary content then you may want to add some additional code to prevent the control from executing its payload one very single site in the web application; likewise, if you are using a custom web template or site definition then you'll want to change the reference to "SPSPERS" in the redirection method.
Remember to add Safe Control entries for the project component which contains your Elements.xml file (from the Properties panel, expand the Safe Control Entries collection and Add a new entry with the proper settings) then add the solution to SharePoint and deploy it to the target web application. You can test it by adding a user to the Site Collection Administrators group for a My Site then attempting to load the My Site home page – the control should kick in and redirect you to that user's "Documents" library. There are probably a number of variations on this approach that would enhance the functionality but this is a quick and simple way to solve the "User not found" issue with Person.aspx.
The full source code for this solution is available here (requires Visual Studio 2013). If you just want the farm solution for deployment in your environment the WSP file can be downloaded separately. If you choose the latter option, please test it in a development farm first as your configuration might be different.
Take the trouble out of troubleshooting.
Anyone who has ever tried to do an in-place upgrade from SharePoint 2007 to 2010 knows what a complete nightmare that process could be; without much effort you could easily destroy a farm and spend endless hours trying to rebuild from scratch. The process was so fragile and prone to failure that in the 2013 release Microsoft removed the option altogether, allowing only content database detach and re-attach migrations. This greatly improved the chances of success and is, for the most part, a pretty seamless operation for the majority of deployments. But every now and then you come across a strange configuration that throws a spanner into the works and turns a simple migration into a huge headache.
Case in point. I recently received a distress call from a user who was trying to migrate a single content database from 2010 to 2013 and getting all sorts of strange results. Although the migration appeared to succeed, all the content was over a year old – documents, sites, list items, customizations – everything was out of date. Initially, it was thought that a second database had been mounted at some point during the preceding year but that wasn't the case – trolling through the SQL server backups it was obvious that there was only ever one database for that web application. Since database corruption is always a possibility, they tried restoring and mounting successive backups going back several months but nothing changed – the old data kept showing up. Running out of time in the assigned maintenance window, the administrator then tried restoring the original database back to 2010 and the same thing happened – old content showed up and the new stuff had simply vanished. Now they really had a problem as both environments, the original 2010 farm and the new 2013 farm, were completely unusable.
Curious as to what might have gone sideways, I had them check the AllDocs and AllLists tables in a copy of the current content database for the latest TimeLastModified value to see if it matched up with the results in the user interface (NOTE: This was an offline copy and not a production database – you should never go poking around in production SharePoint databases). That's when we got a real shock. The database actually contained current lists, documents and list items! Although we couldn't see them when viewing Site Contents, there they were plain as day in the database, with the proper metadata values and template associations. And they weren't hidden, either – attempts to get at them programmatically also failed. Something really weird was going on.
After replicating the steps they took a few times on my own, and getting the same results, I decided to have a look at the upgrade log files. Turns out that even though no errors were displayed during the mount operation there were actually a small number of errors encountered during the upgrade process. The first one I came across made it seem as if whole site collections were missing:
07/20/2014 15:49:45.68 powershell (0x0EAC) 0x20C8 SharePoint Foundation Upgrade SPContentDatabaseSequence ajxkz ERROR Database [WSS_Content] contains a site (Id = [aa3fd23b-5c67-4996-a7c6-773d450945d8], Url = [/sites/abc]) that is not found in the site map. Consider detach and reattach the database.
Well that was obviously nonsense as I knew for a fact that the site collection did exist – I could navigate to it after the upgrade completed. It was followed by a warning indicating that "orphaned sites could cause upgrade failures". Um, yeah, I suppose they would, except there were no orphans in this case – the site really did exist. And then a few lines later I found this little gem:
07/20/2014 15:49:45.68 powershell (0x0EAC) 0x20C8 SharePoint Foundation Upgrade SPContentDatabaseSequence ajxk3 ERROR Database [WSS_Content] contains a site (Id = [aa3fd23b-5c67-4996-a7c6-773d450945d8], Url = [/sites/abc]) whose url is already used by a different site, in database (Id = [973995d8-d187-42c3-890e-04031a48811e], name = [WSS_Content]), in the same web application. Consider deleting one of the sites which have conflicting urls.
Huh? How could two site collections have the same URL? Surely that was nonsense also but just to be sure I ran a quick query against the AllSites table – and stared in disbelief at the results. There were five rows in the table when there should only have been three (that's how many site collections showed up in Central Administration for that web application both before and after the upgrade process). Where did the extra rows come from and what sites did they refer to? Well, as it turned out, they referred to the exact same site collections but with an earlier TimeCreated value. Somehow, site collections had been created, then later re-created with the same URL's, without the old ones being removed from the database. The upgrade operation was obviously using the earlier values when it updated the schema and object associations, which explained why objects existed in the database tables that weren't exposed in the UI – it was just ignoring references to site GUID's that didn't match the two it selected. A quick look back at the AllLists table confirmed it, as tp_SiteId did in fact refer to the earlier site collections.
Now that I knew what was happening, the fix was easy. First, I removed the existing site collections which were based on the old instances, using the Remove-SPSite command. I then dismounted the database and mounted it again. This time, with the old site references gone from the AllSites table, the proper site associations were made and the correct content, including all the lists, libraries, documents and items, was restored. Problem solved. The only remaining mystery was how additional site collections were created with the same URL as ones that were already in the database – this shouldn't be allowed to happen. I still don't have an answer for that but at least the customer was able to carry on with their migration without suffering any data loss. I'll put that one in the "win" column.
PremierPoint Solutions (formerly SharePoint Solutions) has recently released an updated version of their Site Provisioning and Governance Assistant product for on-premise deployments of SharePoint 2010 and 2013. SPGA is designed to address a common concern in enterprise SharePoint deployments – administrative control over site growth and proliferation. Anyone who has ever tried to contain the spread of SharePoint in a manageable and consistent way will appreciate how difficult it can be to enforce governance while at the same time allowing users to use the platform to its full potential.
I was fortunate to have a chance to work with the PremierPoint team to bring the new release of SPGA to market. In conjunction with their Extranet Configuration Manager product, SPGA provides administrators with the ability to define a wide range of rules surrounding the site creation process that support governance policies and objectives. Beyond simple workflows and item-level approvals, SPGA provides a toolbox for implementing flexible and repeatable processes for just about any scenario. This latest release includes some new features and functionality but the real news is that there is now a completely free version. You can download and install it on any SharePoint 2010 or 2013 farm and use the basic out-of-the-box actions without any time-limited expiration. I'm a big fan of the so-called "freemium" model and glad to see more SharePoint ISV's adopting it. Obviously, each vendor would like to you to purchase their product after giving it a spin but if you are satisfied with the no-cost features the hope is that you will provide some word-of-mouth validation in return.
If you are so inclined, give SPGA a try and see how it works for you. You can download it here. If you give it a go be sure to let Jeff and the team at PremierPoint know how you like it and any improvements they can make.
Another year, another TechEd over and done with. It was exciting to have a big technology conference back in the great State of Texas and the City of Houston did us all proud. Great times with great friends and lots of interesting discussions regarding SharePoint, Office 365, Azure, and a bunch of other cool products & technologies.
For those who attended my session on OAuth in SharePoint 2013, links to the slides and code samples can be found below. Thanks to everyone who dropped by, especially the four brave souls who volunteered for my human Token Handler demonstration. Many thanks!
See you next year!
Take the trouble out of troubleshooting.
Another great SPTechCon as come and gone. As always, the team at BZ Media did a great job putting on a top-notch event. Many thanks to everyone who attended my sessions and for all the great questions. Links to the slide decks and demo code can be found below. See you all at the next one!
Get Some REST - Taking Advantage of the SharePoint 2013 REST API
Who are You and What Do You Want? Working with OAuth in SharePoint 2013
Rev Your Engines - SharePoint 2013 Performance Enhancements
Configuring Search in SharePoint 2013 can be a tricky process that is best accomplished via PowerShell scripts. For starters, those messy database names with GUID's in them that get created from UI provisioning are just hideous, but the real issue is that a proper topology (meaning search components running on more than a single machine) can only be deployed via PowerShell cmdlets. Despite our best efforts to script the entire process and avoid the kind of small mistakes that lead to endless hours of frustration, it's inevitable that some small setting or configuration step will crop up that creates a giant headache.
Take, for example, the new "SPSearchDBAdmin" role. This role, which didn't exist in 2010, is added to each search database when it is created in SQL server. If you are following best practices and assigning service accounts for search operations (one for administration, one for crawling, and neither should be the SharePoint Farm or Admin accounts), the account you assign as the Search admin will be added to the SQL logins and given the "public" role. That's all well and good for least privileged purposes but that role alone is insufficient for the Search application to function. Unfortunately, there's no warning about this when the Search service application is created – provisioning will succeed but nothing really works. In order to kick Search into gear, you first need to assign the "SPSearchDBAdmin" role to the Search admin account in SQL server.
Assigning the SPSearchDBAdmin Role in SQL Server Management Studio
Also bear in mind that the Search admin account requires read/write permissions to the folder in which the index files reside. As this account should *not* be a local administrator it's very likely that it won't have access to the folders that hold the primary and replica index files. Be sure to assign the appropriate permissions on each server in the topology which contains an index partition (the default location is "C:\Program Files\Microsoft Office Servers\15.0\Data\Office Server\Applications" which, ideally, should be changed as part of the provisioning process). Possible error messages which indicate your search admin account may not have the correct SQL or folder permissions include:
"Content Plugin can not be initialized - list of CSS addresses is not set."
"Unable to retrieve topology component health states. This may be because the admin component is not up and running"
"Topology activation failed. No system manager locations set, search application might not be ready yet"
"Could not access the Search database. A generic error occurred while trying to access the database to obtain the schema version info."
There are a lot of blogs, forum posts, and articles with all sorts of advice on how to deal with these errors, most of which prescribe repetitive un-provisioning and re-provisioning of service applications. Although those solutions may apply to your environment at some point, before going down that road first ensure that the Search admin account has the proper database and file permissions, as no amount of provisioning will overcome basic security limitations.
(Note: For a good walkthrough on Search provisioning via powershell, refer to this post from Ryan Bushnell and the Search cmdlet reference on TechNet)
Take the trouble out of troubleshooting.
For several years now, Steve Smith and the gang at Combined Knowledge have hosted one of the best SharePoint conferences anywhere in the world. Under various guises as "SharePoint Best Practices Conference", "International SharePoint Conference", or "SharePoint Evolution Conference", this annual London event is something that both the attendees and the speakers look forward to – the information is top-notch, the venue perfectly suited to a mid-size event and the entertainment is out of this world. Unfortunately, due to the timing of the Microsoft SharePoint Conference in Las Vegas this year, the event couldn't be scheduled during April and the Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre is a much sought-after location, being just across the way from the Houses of Parliament and Westminster Abbey, so a later date was logistically infeasible.
So what to do? Well, if you're Steve Smith, you don't just throw in the towel and wait until next year. You take the show on the road! Instead of bringing a bunch of people to a single location, you pack up the whole shebang into a fleet of coaches and send it all across the United Kingdom for three weeks. A crazy idea, to be sure, but no more crazy than putting on a three day event that starts on day one with dozens of top-notch IT Pros and Devs working independently and ends on the final day with a complete set of end-to-end solutions (which we managed to pull off at the International SharePoint Conference 2012 in case you missed it). So why the not give it a go?
And that's exactly what we're going to do. Starting on June 9th, 2014, the SharePoint Evolution Roadshow kicks off in Cardiff, Wales, for a full day jam-packed with sessions from many of your favorite speakers in the global SharePoint community. The show then moves on to London, Cambridge, Birmingham, Nottingham, Manchester, Leeds, and Newcastle, then swings up to Scotland into Edinburgh and Aberdeen, finally wrapping up in Belfast and Dublin on the 24th & 25th of June (I'll be joining the tour for the last portion up north). No matter where you live in the UK an Evolution show is going to be in your neck of the woods this coming June (unless you reside near Fair Isle or Penzance, that is). Even better, the lineup rotates from location to location with only a few speakers going to every city on the tour. So the content will change at each venue, giving you an opportunity to attend more than one event without much overlap. How cool is that?
But the best part is the price. It's only £99 per event! The average cost of a major conference is over £250 per day, making this one of the most affordable learning opportunities anywhere. You just can't beat it. So get out your calendars and AA road planner – it's time for some SharePoint, Evolution style, like nobody else can do it.
For more information and registration details, visit the SharePoint Evolution Conference website.
Take the trouble out of troubleshooting.